By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept

Your #1 guide to start a business and grow it the right way…

InSmartBudget

  • Home
  • Startups
  • Start A Business
    • Business Plans
    • Branding
    • Business Ideas
    • Business Models
    • Fundraising
  • Growing a Business
  • Funding
  • More
    • Tax Preparation
    • Leadership
    • Marketing
Subscribe
Aa
InSmartBudgetInSmartBudget
  • Startups
  • Start A Business
  • Growing a Business
  • Funding
  • Leadership
  • Marketing
  • Tax Preparation
Search
  • Home
  • Startups
  • Start A Business
    • Business Plans
    • Branding
    • Business Ideas
    • Business Models
    • Fundraising
  • Growing a Business
  • Funding
  • More
    • Tax Preparation
    • Leadership
    • Marketing
Made by ThemeRuby using the Foxiz theme Powered by WordPress
InSmartBudget > Startups > FTC v. Meta Trial: The Future of Instagram and WhatsApp Is at Stake

FTC v. Meta Trial: The Future of Instagram and WhatsApp Is at Stake

News Room By News Room April 17, 2025 6 Min Read
Share

The US Federal Trade Commission’s trial against Meta begins in Washington, DC, on Monday, as the tech giant fights to avoid the spinoff of Instagram and WhatsApp. The FTC alleges that Meta illegally acquired the two startups in an effort to suppress competition.

Meta (then called Facebook) bought the photo-sharing startup Instagram for $1 billion in 2012. About two years later, the company snatched up the chat tool WhatsApp for roughly $22 billion.

The FTC, one of the nation’s antitrust enforcement agencies, wants Judge James Boasberg to hold the tech giant liable for executing these mega deals to illegally maintain a social media monopoly. It has called on Boasberg to restore competition by ordering Meta to sell off its prized assets. A victory for the government could deter big tech companies from acquiring startups in the future, cutting off a key source of innovation and investment returns for venture capitalists.

The initial trial could last up to 37 days, wrapping as late as early July. If needed, a trial to decide on penalties would follow—likely next year. Appeals of any rulings could take additional years to resolve. So WhatsApp and Instagram aren’t going on sale anytime soon. But the possibility of losing two valuable properties helps explain why Mark Zuckerberg has reportedly been exploring a last-minute deal with President Donald Trump and White House officials to avert a fight in court. So far, those efforts appear unsuccessful.

Here’s what to expect as the trial kicks off.

What Is the FTC Arguing?

First, the FTC must prove that Facebook has a long-standing monopoly on “providing personal social networking services in the US,” according to its lawsuit. The category Facebook allegedly monopolizes includes services such as Snapchat and little-known MeWe, but notably excludes YouTube, TikTok, and other platforms that the FTC believes are more for watching videos by creators than following family and friends. From 2012 to 2020, Facebook commanded over 80 percent of users’ time per year within this narrowly defined market.

Second, it must show the acquisitions harmed competition in the social networking market. Around the time the Instagram and WhatsApp deal talks began, Facebook feared the threats that app startups posed to its monopoly, according to the lawsuit. Citing emails between Zuckerberg and other company executives—like Zuckerberg writing once that “it is better to buy than compete”—the FTC alleges that the company decided to buy nascent competitors to gain more time to figure out its own app development strategy. “Unable to maintain its monopoly by fairly competing, the company’s executives addressed the existential threat by buying up new innovators that were succeeding where Facebook failed,” the lawsuit alleges.

The FTC claims that after buying Instagram and WhatsApp, Facebook had fewer apps nipping at its heels and got away with providing less data privacy to users and more buggy and expensive services to advertisers. The deals also sent a message to competitors: companies trying to independently beat Facebook wouldn’t be able to get very far, the FTC says. This further stifled competition, according to the lawsuit.

What Does the FTC Want?

The commission would like competition to be restored, including possibly by having Meta divest Instagram and WhatsApp. That could be disastrous for Meta, which relies on Instagram for a significant portion of its ad revenue—an estimated 50 percent or more in the US. Other measures could include blocking Meta from completing similar deals in the future.

What Is Meta’s Defense?

The company’s primary argument is that the commission is defining the market too narrowly. Meta argues that a variety of social apps including TikTok and YouTube are very much competitors to Facebook. Add them into the mix, and Facebook can no longer be viewed as monopolist, the company says.

Should that argument not result in immediate victory for Meta, its other key contention is that the FTC has been unable to demonstrate that consumers and advertisers are worse off because of the company’s ownership of Instagram and WhatsApp—which it views as a requirement for the FTC’s case. Meta has said that the apps would not have become as successful as they are today without its stewardship. “The FTC must prove that consumers would have had more (or better) options sooner without the acquisitions,” the company’s attorneys wrote in court papers last week. “Meta respectfully submits that the FTC will not be able to introduce any evidence to satisfy its burden.”

Read the full article here

News Room April 17, 2025 April 17, 2025
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Copy Link Print
Previous Article Why L.L.Bean is importing Japanese Americana
Next Article How a Mom Started a 6-Figure Side Hustle in Her Kitchen
Leave a comment Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Wake up with our popular morning roundup of the day's top startup and business stories

Stay Updated

Get the latest headlines, discounts for the military community, and guides to maximizing your benefits
Subscribe

Top Picks

Why Entrepreneurs Should Stop Obsessing Over Growth
July 7, 2025
‘Timmy Failure,’ ‘Pearls Before Swine’ Creator Stephan Pastis on Creativity
July 7, 2025
These Startups Are Building Advanced AI Models Without Data Centers
July 7, 2025
The 3 Keys to a Perfect Franchise Fit
July 7, 2025
How Instagram built (and potentially restricted) the link-in-bio industry
July 7, 2025

You Might Also Like

These Startups Are Building Advanced AI Models Without Data Centers

Startups

Airplane Wi-Fi Is Now … Good?

Startups

eBay and Vestiaire Collective Want an Exemption from Trump’s Tariffs

Startups

Venice Braces for Jeff Bezos and Lauren Sanchez’s Wedding

Startups

© 2023 InSmartBudget. All Rights Reserved.

Helpful Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Press Release
  • Advertise
  • Contact

Resources

  • Start A Business
  • Funding
  • Growing a Business
  • Leadership
  • Marketing

Popuplar

He Went From $471K in Debt to Teaching Others How to Succeed
Why Entrepreneurs Are Swapping Beach Vacations for Longevity Retreats
Airplane Wi-Fi Is Now … Good?

We provide daily business and startup news, benefits information, and how to grow your small business, follow us now to get the news that matters to you.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?